Showing posts with label Miranda. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Miranda. Show all posts

Sixth Circuit reversed . . . again

On November 7, the Supreme Court reversed the Sixth Circuit's decision in Dixon v. Houck, in which the Court had overturned the conviction and death sentence of the defendant based upon Miranda violations.  The Supreme Court dealt unusually harshly with the Sixth Circuit in a per curium opinion, finding, for example, that  "according to the Sixth Circuit, the Miranda decision itself clearly established that police could not speak to Dixon on November 9, because on November 4 Dixon had refused to speak to police without his lawyer. That is plainly wrong." (emphasis added)  The Supreme Court dismissed each of the grounds for reversal set forth in the Sixth Circuit's opinion in short, order, and seemed to re-affirm the deference given to state court opinions, finding "Because no precedent of this Court required Ohio to do more, the Sixth Circuit was without authority to overturn the reasoned judgment of the State’s highest court."

The Supreme Court's opinion can be found here.

Four New Supreme Court Decisions

Yesterday, the Supreme Court issued opinions in four criminal cases:

In J.D.B. v. North Carolina, the Supreme Court has broadened use of the Miranda warning for suspects, extending it to children questioned by police in school. By a 5-to-4 vote, the court said for the first time that age must be considered in determining whether a suspect is aware of his or her rights.

In Tapia v. United States, the Supreme Court ruled unanimously that a federal judge cannot impose a longer prison sentence than what the sentencing guidelines permit simply to promote rehabilitation.

In Davis v. United States, the Supreme Court upheld the conviction of an Alabama man by a vote of 7-2, though the justices agreed the search that produced the incriminating evidence was illegal. The Court refused to disturb the firearm conviction, declaring that at the time the search was conducted, police relied in good faith on existing law.

In Bond v. United States, the Supreme Court ruled unanimously that citizens, not just states, has standing to challenge the validity of the statute (federal laws implementing the chemical weapons treaty) on the ground that it infringes on the powers reserved to the states under the Tenth Amendment.

NPR Online also offers commentary on the opinions.

Court grants habeas relief on Miranda violation

Today, the Court issued an opinion in Fields v. Howe, Case no. 09-1215, in which the Court upheld the granting of a habeas petition based upon a failure to provide Miranda warnings to an inmate in custody at a state facility.

The defendant was a state inmate, incarcerated on charges unrelated to those under investigation. At some point, detectives pulled the defendant from population, placed him a locked room, and interrogated him for up to 7 hours. Although they told the defendant he was free to leave, they did not read him Miranda warnings, and used force (through a corrections officer and by locking the door).

The Court held that "Because Fields was removed from the general prison population for interrogation about an offense unrelated to the one for which he was incarcerated, Mathis is the applicable law. None of the cited appellate cases, all of which were decided subsequent to Mathis, erode its essential holding: Miranda warnings must be administered when law enforcement officers remove an inmate from the general prison population and interrogate him regarding criminal conduct that took place outside the jail or prison."

The Court went so far as to call their ruling a bright line test, requiring - "A Miranda warning must be given when an inmate is isolated from the general prison population and interrogated about conduct occurring outside of the prison."